A directive issued by the J&K Government’s Department of Culture, mandating schools across the Union Territory to organise musical and cultural programmes commemorating the 150th year of the national song Vande Mataram, has drawn sharp protests from Muslim religious organisations, reported India Today.
The order requires participation of all students and staff in the themed events, a condition that critics say crosses the line into coercion. According to the directive, schools must hold assemblies and programmes between October 31 and November 7, 2025, where Vande Mataram will be recited or sung.
The umbrella body of Muslim religious organisations in J&K, the Muttahida Majlis‑e‑Ulema (MMU), has described the order as unjustifiable, “coercive” and un-Islamic. The MMU argues that singing or recitation of the song conflicts with Islamic principles of monotheism, as it includes expressions of reverence which, they say, Muslims believe should be reserved for the Creator alone. The statement issued by the MMU, headed by Mirwaiz Umar Farooq, appeals to the Lieutenant Governor and Chief Minister of J&K to immediately withdraw the directive and ensure no student or institution is compelled to act against their religious beliefs.
The MMU’s contention is that while Muslims deeply love their homeland, such patriotism should be expressed through service, compassion, and societal contribution — not through acts they believe challenge their faith. They further assert that the directive appears aimed at imposing a Hindutva-driven ideology rather than promoting genuine unity and respect for diversity in a region with a Muslim majority.
The government’s rationale behind the directive is rooted in the national celebration of 150 years of Vande Mataram, a song first published in 1875 which later became a symbol of India’s freedom movement. The J&K administration has assigned the Education Directors as the nodal officers for coordinating school-level programmes and emphasised that the participation of schools is crucial for wider outreach and meaningful student involvement.
Education sector officials indicate that the circular emphasised “structured musical and cultural programmes” to engage young students in commemorating the national song’s legacy. In doing so, the administration hopes to instil national pride and cultural awareness among school-going children.
Analysts believe this controversy highlights a broader tension in India: the intersection of state-led cultural initiatives and the religious sensibilities of minorities. In the case of J&K, the mandatory nature of the directive is seen as especially sensitive given the region’s demographic and historical context. Some educators have raised questions about whether participation should indeed be compulsory, given the possibility of conflict with faith-based conscience rights.
The MMU warned that if the direction is not withdrawn, they may convene a meeting of all religious leadership in the region to deliberate on further response. As of now, no formal response from the J&K administration has been publicly released, and the situation remains under watch.
For schools in J&K, the order presents a practical challenge: manage compliance with government instructions while respecting the diversity of student backgrounds and preventing potential uproar. For parents and students alike, the debate raises fundamental questions about the nature of patriotism, the scope of school-led cultural programmes, and the boundaries of state mandates in plural societies.
Photo Source: X
For more stories click here
Follow us for latest updates:
